OT Day: A Rant From a Rerider

Yes, this is a rant post. Nothing to do with Lucky, who is still fine. I’m tempted to rant about the cat (whichever one it was) that peed in the living room. However, that happens.

No, instead, this is triggered by a rash of posts lately on Chronicle Forums of people “outing” owners whose horses end up in kill pens, demanding registration papers from a breeder on a yearling filly purchased as a grade quarter horse who turned out to be a freeze-branded Standardbred given away unpapered by her breeders, and general attempts to form lynch mobs based on horses bought from brokers as ‘rescues.’ Strictly speaking, they are saved, as the brokers can ship to Canada or Mexico for slaughter. And obviously, the brokers didn’t pluck these horses out of thin air.

But I’m not tying up the noose. I’m not ready to string up old owners or create blacklists of trainers or march on the breeding farm demanding papers.

Brokers: I don’t hold their jobs against them. I’m not prepared to keep every horse forever, pay for euthanasia and safe disposal of a barbiturate-contaminated body for every horse that doesn’t have a home. And I certainly don’t blame brokers for marking up their horses when they’re selling them to would-be rescuers. They didn’t put the horses in an auction where anyone can bid on them, and most do not get into massive bidding wars–if someone else wants a horse and is willing to pay, they bid on something else.

Owners and breeders: As far as selling at a low-end auction–no, it’s not something I’m likely to do. Certainly not Lucky-he’s the kind of horse a private buyer would buy. And I would hope that if I did have a horse that no one wanted and I couldn’t keep, or who was genuinely dangerous, I would have the cojones to put him down myself or find someone with a humane killer. But I don’t own every horse in the world (thank God; I don’t have that kind of money.) I don’t want people coming into my barn and telling me what I can and cannot do with my own horse, and therefore I’m not going into other people’s barns doing likewise. I wouldn’t chemically euthanize if at all avoidable, either–I’d rather have a body that can be safely buried, composted, or fed out. Some people think that’s horrible. Some people probably think it’s horrible I don’t use boots or polos to ride, I don’t have six blankets for every possible weather condition, and that I’ll use a bit stronger than a Dee ring if I think it’ll get me better results. When they’re paying me to ride their horse, their opinions will matter. Likewise, if I’m buying their horse, their means of selling it is my business, but if I’m not putting my money where my mouth is, my mouth stays shut. And who am I to DEMAND that a breeder register every last horse that hits the ground? Because the horse ‘deserves its identity?’

Bull. Shit.

(It’s my blog and I’ll swear if I want to.)

The situation, for those who don’t want to prowl the forums: a person purchased a horse from a broker lot long-distance. The horse was auctioned, advertised, and purchased as a suspected Quarter Horse with no papers. When she arrived, she was freeze branded, and turned out to have come from a Standardbred farm. The new owner informed the breeders (I assume politely) that they’d bought the horse from a ‘kill buyer’ and traced her via her brand, and would the breeder provide the registration papers. The breeder (also politely, I would assume) replied that they have given the filly away to someone who had apparently sent her to auction, and no, they would not turn over the papers. The new owner’s friend posted on the forums seeking a way to circumvent the breeders, saying that the purchaser is entitled to the papers so that the filly might be trained to race or bred. When it was pointed out that first, the USTA will provide ‘pleasure papers’ to horses in precisely the filly’s situation (something I don’t think any other registry does) allowing the horse to be sold or shown as a registered Standardbred, but not raced or bred, and second, the filly probably did not end up being given away because she was a promising broodmare or race prospect, the story became that the horse was entitled to its identity, and that having papers would “protect” it in the future.

Two things about this hacked me off. First, there is often a call for breeders to be responsible for their horses. People who have never been commercial or race breeders insist that there are too many Thoroughbreds or Standardbreds rescued, that the breeders must be responsible for and prepared to “take back” any horse they ever bred that falls on hard times, no matter where or when. They breed too many, those horses gets raced and broken down, they should be responsible. Well, this breeder apparently tried to be responsible by culling a filly that for whatever reason they not only didn’t think should be raced, but was not a good candidate to be kept as a broodmare. Or maybe they simply couldn’t afford to keep a yearling, pay her upkeep, until she was old enough. In any case, they opted to give her away without papers (and so far there isn’t any indication the papers exist any more). Now, could they have done a better job “rehoming” her? Apparently. But I don’t see people lining up at breeders’ doors for horses that aren’t quite right for the track. I do see breeders getting rid of excess stock being told they just breed too much. Since I’ve never met a horse who lived free, what exactly were they supposed to do if no buyers came calling? The old practice of taking the culls out behind the barn with a shotgun slug isn’t exactly a fan favorite, either. Was the “moral” option to try and sell a horse that they didn’t believe in as a racehorse to the racing market anyway, likely setting her on the road to a low-level career and being sold off after she’s broken down? Yeah, she was given away to someone who turned out not to have her best interests at heart. But shy of running a background check on every person interested in one of their horses, what should a breeder do when no one turns up with cash? Or there’s nowhere to advertise, or no one is biting where they do? How many cheap craigslist horses get passed over until they are in broker lot, marked up from their craigslist price with a week to go until they ship to Canada, when suddenly they’re a cause? What’s a breeder with culled stock supposed to do if there’s only interest once the horse is on the proverbial Death Row, and someone else is pocketing the money?

Second thing that hacked me off was the idea that the filly herself “deserves” her papers, and that somehow having papers in hand will protect her. The more I think on it, the more problems I have with this argument. The smallest and easiest to address is that in this case, this horse DOES have an identity. It’s branded on her neck for life. It’s obviously easy to trace as they found her breeders. Second, almost as easy to address–just because you have papers in a auction office that supposedly go with that horse, how do you know? If it’s not a TB or an STB who’s been tattooed or branded, how do you know this “Bay Quarter Horse Mare” is the one the broker is selling you? There are stories of brokers tossing papers in trash cans, keeping a set they use over and over for trips across the border where the named horses are long gone, and at least one case turned up on Another Chance For Horses where AC4H was fairly certain the papers that had come with the mare weren’t hers. Third, if you are not planning to breed or race, what exactly do you need those papers for? The Jockey Club requires they be handed on without charge to owners, but sometimes papers are lost, left in a track office, sitting in the wrong file. If you aren’t breeding, and if you are buying horses out of auction pens chances are you aren’t or shouldn’t be for a variety of reasons, and you aren’t going to race them (and horses who make profitable race horses and are likely to KEEP making money generally don’t get sold per pound–they are being dumped because they are no longer cost-effective for whatever reason) what does that paper do?

Fourth, and the more I think the more horrible this argument is, is the idea that simply having papers ‘protects’ the horse. I can’t even begin to describe how many things are wrong with this argument. The most glaring is: that horse you pulled out of a kill pen who had papers? WAS IN A KILL PEN, MORON. Having papers didn’t keep him from ending up there in the first place. Second, it assumes that horses ONLY have value if they are a purebred with papers to prove it. Performance and utility mean nothing without that little slip saying they can trace their parentage to some foundation sire or other. I grew up riding grade horses who were by and large not purebred anything and whose parents weren’t even known, they were so far removed from their breeding. That didn’t make them worthless–my friends and neighbors had them to ride, to have in the backyard to keep the grass down, to cross on a donkey to get a nice-looking mule. They had value because of what they DID, not who their sire and dam were. Not as much as, say, a warmblood bred from imported semen and a branded, inspected mare, but the people who owned them weren’t going to buy a $20,000 horse in the first place. And it’s not just backyards–my brother currently lessons at a very nice barn in New York, where one of the horses he routinely rides is a good old-fashioned American Mutt, as far as they know. He doesn’t look like a warmblood, he doesn’t seem to be a thoroughbred, he might be a quarter horse cross of some kind, but as he was seized by the SPCA, he didn’t come with papers and a life history. What he did come with was a love of jumping fast! Does he have value? Well, he’d probably be for sale for the right price, but it’s not a price I could ever afford! Is he unprotected because he has no papers? No, because he is a trained horse who is valuable because of what he does.

Conversely, by the standards of those who think even setting foot on a track (because horses only break down from racing, donchaknow, and race owners don’t care about their welfare at all) is putting the horse in danger, and hey, claiming ranks, anyone can take him home, is Lucky safe because I have his papers? Because with those papers, I can race him if I want to (until he’s old enough the stewards won’t allow me to restart him, at any rate.) If he were intact or a mare, I could breed him as many times as I wanted for sale–he probably wouldn’t produce much of note, but there’s a market for low-end racers, at least until they need to be moved on and no one wants them until they’re a rescue. If I didn’t have his papers, it wouldn’t matter if he was able to breed–they’d be unregisterable. I couldn’t race him.

And also–isn’t the assumption that the person who is buying that horse out of a kill pen does not want that horse to end up back in the lot and on the truck. So, exactly what sort of protection does the horse need? If they are indeed a cheap grade horse, is this new owner going to sell him to anyone who shows up with cash? Do they care less about the horse because it doesn’t have papers in hand? If I bought a horse, it is MY RESPONSIBILITY. Whether it has papers or not, if I care about that horse not ending up someplace less than pleasant, be it a kill pen, a barbed-wire pen, or turned loose to starve to death in a state park somewhere, I have to be responsible. If I am the “forever home” and I will never sell, I need to plan for that, including what to do if I am no longer able to care for him. If I sell him, I need to know who is buying him. I need a bill of sale showing how much they paid and where they came from. I need to check on where they’re going to keep him, see for myself that references are real. And then I need to acknowledge that once I do sell, I no longer have control, and I have to accept that. Maybe, if the horse doesn’t have papers or isn’t even a purebred anything, I don’t get quite as much money. But if I wanted to sell horses for huge profits in specific breeds, I would be going out looking for proven animals or well-bred ones. If I am reselling a horse I “upgraded”, from craigslist or a kill pen, I am presumably doing it mostly to give that horse a chance at a better life. A horse without papers is not less deserving of that courtesy.

I got a snotty reply that don’t I have papers for Lucky? Yes, yes I do. They’re in the same muddy envelope Jared put them in when he sold Lucky to a buyer seven hundred miles away on the basis of a few phone calls and an overnighted check, who’d only known the horse existed because FLTAP provides a means for trainers to shop these horses to buyers not in the Farmington area. They were handy for checking his tattoo against his papers (mixups do happen, and one bay 16hh TB can look a lot like another!) and I haven’t had any call to need them since. Did I want his papers? Sure.

Here’s the difference: I was purchasing Lucky To Cope, a 2002 bay gelding by Lucky Lionel out of Copenqueen by Copelan, foaled in Florida, last owner and trainer of record Jared Schoeneman, last start on November 5, 2009, at Finger Lakes Gaming and Racetrack, Farmington, New York. That was the horse advertised by name, examined by a vet for me, whose personality and behavior I inquired about. Did I want the easiest method of making sure the horse my hauler brought off the trailer was in fact the horse I paid for? Of course, and checking his tattoo against his papers is easier than checking it against the tattoo search.

I was NOT purchasing a bay gelding, presumably a thoroughbred, tattoo says a 2002 model, number might match a horse named Lucky To Cope, but those ARE hard to read, out of an auction back lot where the broker has no idea who the last owners were or why he’s there. If I call up Camelot or Enumclaw or the intermediaries at AC4H and buy hip #101, I just bought a bay thoroughbred. He might have papers. They might be sitting in a track office. They might have gone in the auction garbage can. If I can identify him and if some previous owner is found and IF they have the papers and hand them over, that’s nice. If the tattoo’s unreadable, if the last owner is dead or moved to Argentina or just never returns my calls…I still own that horse. I’m still responsible for that horse. The only one who is going to guarantee he never ends up in a Canadian feedlot is, guess who, ME. Not his breeders, not his old owners, certainly not the broker who’s just making a living off horses no one else wanted to buy when anyone could buy them, but me, the one who plunked down the cash for an unknown quantity. Just the same as if he was sired by shipped semen from an Olympic gold-medal-winning stallion with an embryo transfer from a Rolex-winning mare with papers for three registries, I am responsible for protecting him, even if he’s a Cremello Arapintapalaloosa Spotted Walking Pony with donkey ears who has no value except as an object lesson in why you shouldn’t breed it just because its genitals are functional. I bought it, I am responsible for its welfare.

The best way to be responsible for that horse? Make it the best citizen it can be. It might have all the papers in the world but if it kicks the crap out of you for coming in its stall or trying to saddle it, if it can’t be ridden except by the lab-created offspring of George Morris, Alois Podhajski and Julie Krone and then only if that uberrider is having a REALLY good day, if it is just a bad-mannered, poorly-trained horse, you might as well shred those papers yourself because the horse can’t be used, and no one in their right mind or who cared about a breed would want it to reproduce itself. Conversely, it might only be a plain bay backyard-bred quarter/paint/whatever grade horse, but if it can jump a 2’6″ course neatly, pack the little lesson kids around, or handle an all-day trail ride with phlegmatic aplomb and will even forgive the new guy in the barn brushing his hair backwards and mixing up the fly spray with the Show Sheen, that horse has value. Lucky is never going to make little racehorses, he’s never going win money at the track (unless we move to a state where on-line gaming is legal and he learns to hack my TVG account), but you can put a little kid on him. You can float his teeth without a tranquilizer. You can gallop him in a field and then ask him for an even trot in an arena. I’m not selling him, but if I wanted to, he has value, not because of what his papers say, but what he does.

You want to save horses? Give breeders, owners, and trainers ways to market the horses that don’t suit their purposes BEFORE it’s the last day of the season, they have nowhere to go, and nowhere to winter the horses. Do not tell them what horrible people they are and tell them you’re “saving” their horse from them. Go to an auction and outbid the kill buyer. And when you have that horse, teach him to be useful. And don’t sell him if you aren’t comfortable with where he’s going. The papers aren’t going to save the horse from future disaster. You are.


7 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. Natalie Keller Reinert
    Jun 30, 2010 @ 06:50:36


    Sister sister, preach it sister.

    I would have amazing commentary to grace this fantastic rant with, but A) it isn’t necessary and 2) I haven’t had enough sleep to coherently write anything. Suffice it to say that I couldn’t agree more with this post.


    • The Author
      Jun 30, 2010 @ 08:37:16

      Sleep is important–I gather you arrived safely? Driving tires me out.

      And yes ranty mcranting here, but GEEZ, people–Lucky’s not going to end up in a kill pen because *I’m not going to let him end up there.* Not because he’s papered, because he’s MINE!


  2. Louise
    Jun 30, 2010 @ 07:29:53

    “The papers aren’t going to save the horse from future disaster. You are.”

    And, there, in your last sentence, is the whole enchilada. Wonderful post, Dancer. Gives you lots to think about.


  3. Linda
    Jun 30, 2010 @ 08:40:03

    Really great post. Rant away 🙂


  4. Kris Dow
    Jul 09, 2010 @ 21:26:13

    I think if a horse HAS papers, then they should be transferred with the horse, if only for the information value – if you know the horse’s breeding then you can potentially look up if there’s a history of certain types of health problems in those lines, and so perhaps treat the horse differently than you would otherwise. However, if you buy a horse without papers (as in, not advertised with papers, not mentioned in the sale that it would come with papers) then, well. Too bad for you. It’s probably not going to hurt to POLITELY contact someone, to see if you can get the papers (or at least confirm the horse’s suspected identity) or get assistance getting those ‘pleasure’ papers if that’s necessary, but if they say no, well. You still have the horse. There’s plenty of cheesy ‘registries’ out there you can sign up with if you just want a nice piece of paper. (Heck, *I* have nice certificate paper and a laser printer from a film project – I could start my own registry!)

    As far as grade horses – every single horse I learned to ride on was some type of mystery mutt, because the guy who ran the lesson barn didn’t see any point in spending tons on push-button, high-priced WBs when the goal was to learn to ride. (I am not, in all fairness, entirely convinced he didn’t intentionally occasionally buy the really ornery ones, just to make us work harder at learning how to really ride and handle horses.) Playing guess-the-possible-breeds was a fairly common tacking-for-a-group-lesson past time.

    Unless you specifically intend to breed, if your horse can do the job you want, be happy. If he can’t, put some training on him so he can find a good home, and sell him and buy one who can do what you want. That’s how it works.

    (In defense of the guy who ran the lesson barn, I will add that none of the horses were actually dangerous. He just didn’t see any reason why you shouldn’t learn how to ride a horse who had an attitude and would express quite strongly his opinion that the lesson was over by going and standing in the middle of the arena like a big furry rock just as much as you should learn to ride on horses who needed a more delicate touch.)


  5. Cranky Person
    Aug 21, 2010 @ 01:38:50

    I disagree. I think that breeders *SHOULD* be responsible for what they have bred. If you don’t want a horse bred on – geld it or spay it. Withholding papers is silly and childish.

    If breeders thought more carefully about the results of their breeding program, they wouldn’t have to worry so much about the hundreds of horses they are responsible for producing – first because those horses would be highly sought after and second because there would be fewer of them in the first place.

    I see nothing wrong with the SB owner wanting the papers, and everything wrong with the breeder not producing them. If the horse is entitled to be a full member of a breed registry why wouldn’t they allow it? If they aren’t proud of what they bred, why did they breed it in the first place?

    As far as coming into your barn or not coming into your barn – damn straight I’ll come in if you are doing something dangerous for your horse. Your feelings are far less important to protect than an innocent animal who cannot speak for him or herself.

    Just because the new owners paid a less-than-premium price for the horse doesn’t mean they shouldn’t get the papers. I am not privy to the whole situation but in general, I think a registered horse is more salable than a grade horse, and so the papers would help the horse if needed.


    • The Author
      Aug 21, 2010 @ 10:32:29

      As far as coming into your barn or not coming into your barn – damn straight I’ll come in if you are doing something dangerous for your horse. Your feelings are far less important to protect than an innocent animal who cannot speak for him or herself.

      So what do you deem dangerous? What standards do you apply? Beyond the bare minimum (the animal appears in reasonable health and is not posing a public-health or agricultural/disease hazard to others) everything about horses is subjective. Blanketing or not in wet/cold weather? Feeding this hay over that? Electrobraid, wire, wood, t-posts, for fencing? Hobbling/tying or not tying? Riding in winter if the horse isn’t body-clipped? Shod/unshod? (The barefoot crowd would tell you shoeing is dangerous.) What sort of footing is acceptable or unacceptable? I don’t like brick aisles–they cause slips and injuries. A whole lot of BNT barns are dangerous by that standard. Nylon, leather, rope halter? I use a chain shank–do I want some Parellite wandering into the barn and telling me that’s horribly cruel and I should use a rope halter? Stabling all day? Turnout/no turnout? Riding without a helmet? Riding without leg wraps? How about storing hay or bedding in the same building?

      Also: as in this situation (where the mare was clearly branded and identifiable) how precisely did being obviously registered and traceable help her? How did it help every quarter horse, paint, Morgan who comes through AC4H every single week with papers attached? For rarer breeds, sometimes that’s enough to get a rescue. Otherwise–it didn’t do a damn thing. The quarter horses and paints, who are a dime a dozen, go right on UNLESS their videos show they have some usable value. That’s what saves horses–that you can throw a saddle on them, stick a kid on their back, hitch them to a buggy, and DO SOMETHING. Well, that and being owned by people who are not going to sell them down the road to the first person with cash. I always suspect the motives of those so deeply concerned with the horse’s future because they could ALWAYS end up in a bad place–really? You’re going to just sell them any old place? You’re going to realize it’s just a grade mare and you can’t sell her foals for any money and haul her back to Sugar Creek or Enumclaw or New Holland or Camelot? Because that’s the only way she’s ever in danger again–if YOU are irresponsible.

      That kind of irrational, emotive behavior (“I can trespass, threaten, and do whatever I want on/to another person’s private property if I deem a situation is unacceptable”) is what kills animals. Because then owners just aren’t going to deal with you. Better the horse be sold straight to a broker. Better for the broker not to allow anyone on his property and just sell straight to auction.

      As for breeders–I hope you don’t buy horses. Or are prepared to hand them back over to their breeders when they decide that something you do in terms of horse management is ‘dangerous.’ And to take on the horses when breeders have to shut down because they’re now supposed to care for everything they ever put on the ground.

      And I sincerely hope that every single person (generally rich, white and privileged hobby horse owners) who proclaims that euthanasia is always the answer and no one should EVER sell a horse into a less-than-perfect situation is ready both to pick up the tab for the euthanasia and to push the plunger on a healthy horse themselves. Seriously. You are so determined that it’s better they be killed than sold at auction? You do it. Personally. Your own hands. See how long you last.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: